Leading fire fighting foam manufacturers respond to hemmingfire.com’s report on The Madrid Statement

Published:  20 November, 2014

‘Short-chain (C6) Fluorotelomer-based AFFF Foams are neither bioaccumulative nor harmful.’

On October 27th hemmingfire.com published an article entitled: ‘Worldwide scientific community unites to highlight that PFASs substances are persistent and harmful – which includes C6 fluorinated AFFF foams’.

The article reported on The Madrid Statement, which documents scientific consensus regarding the persistence and potential for harm of poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs), and lays out a roadmap to gather needed information and prevent further harm.

The Fire Fighting Foam Coalition (FFFC) – a not-for-profit trade association whose members are manufacturers, distributors and users of aqueous film-forming foam (AFFF) fire fighting agents and their chemical components – has sent the following response:

Short-chain (C6) Fluorotelomer-based AFFF Foams are neither bioaccumulative nor harmful

The headline to the article posted October 27 is alarmingly misleading. The Helsingor and Madrid Statements referenced in the article do not say that the short-chain (C6) fluorochemicals used in modern AFFF agents are ‘harmful’. In fact, the Helsingor and Madrid Statements make no direct mention at all of the use of fluorochemicals in fire fighting foam. In addition, both statements note the scientific consensus that while short-chain fluorochemicals are persistent, they are ‘less bioaccumulative’ than long-chain fluorochemicals. Indeed, they are not considered PBTs (persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic). It is disappointing that a leading fire protection industry website did not provide a more balanced and informed view of this issue.

The Helsingor Statement is published in a scientific journal and represents the views of six prominent researchers in the field of poly-and perfluorinated substances (PFASs). The Madrid Statement on the other hand was published by the Green Science Policy Institute, an environmental organization located in Berkeley, California, and many of its 177 signatories are non-scientists. Thus, it is inaccurate and a gross exaggeration to refer to either statement as representing the views of the ‘worldwide scientific community.’

The Helsingor and Madrid Statements broadly address the transition from long-chain PFASs to short-chain fluorinated alternatives, which are used in textiles, paints and coatings, adhesives, and fire fighting foams. They express concern for the ‘potential impacts’ and the ‘potential for harm’ from the widespread use of fluorinated alternatives. At the same time, both statements acknowledge the need to use fluorinated alternatives where they are ‘essential’ and have been found to be ‘indispensable.’ AFFF foams are the most effective agents currently available to protect life and high-value property from the risk of flammable liquid fires in military, oil and gas, municipal, and aviation applications. It seems reasonable to conclude that the signers of the two statements would consider the use of fluorinated alternatives in AFFF foams to meet those criteria. In fact, it is difficult to imagine a use of fluorochemicals that has a higher societal value than fire fighting foam.

One of the key concerns expressed in the two statements is that there is limited information available on the use, properties, chemical structures, and environmental impacts of fluorinated alternatives. While this may be true for some fluorinated alternatives, it is definitely not true for the short-chain (C6) fluorotelomer-based surfactants used in fire fighting foams. Short-chain fluorosurfactants have been used in fire fighting foams for more than 30 years. Their use patterns, quantities of use, chemical structures, and potential breakdown products are well known and have been published in numerous journal articles and industry reports. They have undergone extensive environmental testing that has been published in peer reviewed scientific journals, and have been shown to be low in toxicity and not bioaccumulative.

Another key concern expressed in the two statements is the possible need to use additional quantities of fluorinated alternatives to meet the same performance level as long-chain PFASs, thus increasing the environmental burden. While this may be true for some applications, it is not necessarily true for fire fighting foams. There have been AFFF agents on the market for 30 years that contain over 95% C6-based fluorosurfactants and meet the most challenging foam industry standards, such as US Mil-F-24385 specifications. In addition, manufacturers have developed new AFFF formulations using pure C6-based fluorosurfactants that can meet these same standards with fluorine levels well within historical ranges.

The fire protection industry understands the need to be good environmental stewards of the chemicals used to suppress fires and explosions. The foam industry began including information on methods to control, collect, treat, and properly dispose of foam discharges in its standards in 1998.  In recent years the industry has expanded that information to focus on minimizing discharges of all foams, and in some cases replacing the use of AFFF for training and equipment testing with alternative fluids and methods. Based on discussions at recent industry conferences, it appears that most foam users have already embraced these environmentally responsible practices.

It would be helpful in the future if this website would resist the temptation to overly sensationalize important and complex issues such as these, and instead provide fire professionals with the fact-based information they need.

FFFC Members: Angus Fire, Ansul, Chemguard, Dr. Sthamer, DuPont, Dynax, Eau & Feu, Fire Service Plus, Fomtec, ICL, Kerr Fire, Kidron, National Foam, Williams Fire & Hazard.

  • Operation Florian

Sign up: eMagazine & eNewsletter

The latest issues in your inbox.

Company Profiles

Renka´s Fire Engine No. 1

Firefighting, fast, safe, everywhere. Michael Renka GmbH, based in Germany, is a manufacturer of firefighting vehicles, pumps and rescue equipment.

Waterax - We move water

Trusted by wildland firefighters around the world, WATERAX sets the industry standard by developing innovative, portable fire pumps and water-handling equipment designed to withstand demanding applications and rugged environments.

Big Water Flow for Industrial and Municipal Firefighting Applications

Protecting the lives of the public and firefighters while limiting the structural damage caused in large scale fires is our primary mission

We are committed to improving lives and doing business in the right way

We have a unique mix of capability and culture that we refer to as 3M Science and we strive to develop products that improve people’s daily lives in a multitude of ways.

HazSim - Bringing situational HazMat training to life

HazSim, LLC provides innovative simulation training to ensure your team works safely and effectively. HazSim Pro simulation equipment is in use by hundreds of fire departments, training schools, industrial fire teams, and private trainers across the US, Canada and further afield as well as the US Army.

The ultimate in innovation, quality and service

For 60 years Lehavot has been delivering the world’s most advanced fire detection and suppression automatic systems

Advancing rescue technology

The specialist supplier of quality PPE and Rescue Equipment to Emergency Services.

Revolutionizing fire fighting foam technology

The one-stop resource for fire fighting foam concentrates and custom-designed foam suppression systems hardware.

Trust the best, let us be your foam solution

AUXQUIMIA is a Spanish company whose main activity is the design, manufacture and commercialization of firefighting foam concentrates.

Williams Fire & Hazard Control offers a full line of specialized fire response equipment for oil and gas platforms

From storage tanks and pipeline emergencies to offshore platforms and vessels at sea, Williams' response personnel and specialized equipment quickly address adverse fire emergencies.

The leader in truck-mounted hydraulic platforms

Our mission is to provide the best and the safest solution to professionals that work at height.

If you want quality, you want Zico

Since its inception Ziamatic Corp has provided the men and women of the fire service with products designed to make their jobs safer and easier.

The independent alternative

Dafo Fomtec AB is a privately owned company with head office in Stockholm Sweden and manufacturing in Helsingborg in the south of Sweden.